So Molly wanted a taste of fall. She was really missing all the beautiful colors and flavors, and she requested her favorite fall soup – “Pumpkin Pie Soup.” It was loosely based on a soup recipe from my sister Maria, and I set out to recreate it in Siwa.
It took about 2 weeks, given that every ‘simple’ ingredient needed to be found, made, or substituted. – I didn’t have the recipe, so I was going to have to wing it. As best I could remember, the ingredient list was:
- “Pumpkin Pie Soup”
- Roasted Butternut Squash
- Pumpkin Pie Spice
- Chicken or Veggie Stock
- Cream Cheese
Spices first. There are a lot of spice shops in Siwa, so we visited a few and, through some pretty impressive gestures and miming, were able to get small little packets of ginger, cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg (most of the ingredients for pumpkin pie spice mix). Allspice was not a thing, so I just skipped it. I couldn’t get all of the spices ground, so I used a blender and did my best.
Butternut Squash – There were baking pumpkins, so I found one at the market, along with 3 sweet potatoes to balance the flavor. We had a gas stove in the Shali house, but there wasn’t really a temperature setting option – fire on top, fire on bottom, off. We also decided to do most of the roasting late at night because the stove gave off a lot of heat which would be uncomfortable during the hot part of the day. The video shows other cooking that took place when they roasted the pumpkin (FYI: The cookie bars were delicious!!)
Chicken stock: This one was tricky – not something that can just be purchased from a store in Siwa. Youssef helped us get a “balady chicken” from the market, and a couple hours in a pot gave us some delicious chicken stock.
Cream cheese: Surprisingly this was the easiest thing to find. Apparently cream cheese is a thing in Egypt!
After roasting the pumpkin and sweet potatoes, Camila bought us a blender for the Shali House, so we blended everything together, warmed it on the stovetop, and successfully made fall Pumpkin Pie Soup in the middle of the Egyptian desert!!

